Creating
Conflict
Backstory
Finding a
Critique Group
Writing a
Synopsis
Word
Count
Plotting
In Layers
What Your Query
Says About Your Book
Describing
Your Characters
Point of View
& Characters
The First
250 Words
Passive
Voice

Is Your Writing
Getting Better?
Finding
an Agent
Tips On
Writing Action
Nice Writer
Syndrome?
Red Flag: Words
That Are Trouble
Plotting
The First
Draft
Edit -vs- Revise:
Deathmatch!
Guest Author
Claudia Gray
On Outlining
Guest Author
Kody Keplinger
On Dialog
Guest Author
Cynthia L. Smith
On Process
Guest Author
K.A. Stewart
On Character
Guest Author
Jana DeLeon
On Pantsing
Guest Author
Holly Cupala
On Writing Secrets
Guest Author
Nancy Holzner
On Dialog
Guest Author
Gini Koch
On Process
Guest Author
Vincent H O'Neil
On Research
Online
Resources
Books by
Janice Hardy
The Shifter
by Janice Hardy
Blue Fire
by Janice Hardy
8 Against Reality
inc. Janice Hardy
Diagnostics:
Submit Your Work

Wednesday, January 19, 2011

Keeping Your Distance: Narrative Distance

I talked a little about narrative distance on Monday, but I thought it might be worth a deeper look today, especially for those who are trying to deepen or widen their POV during revisions. Narrative distance is that feeling of closeness (or lack thereof) between the reader and the characters. There's no right narrative distance, and it' up to the writer to decide where they want the reader to be. But it's easy to fall into that "limbo narrative" (thanks to CE for coining the phrase) where it isn't really clear where your narrator is.

There are some common words help determine narrative distance. If you're unsure where your narrator is, or want to get close or farther away, here are some samples of things to search for:

Stage Directions
These are the little words like "to" and "for" that imply motive. In a close POV, you show the action and let the reader figure out the motivations by what's said and done. A more distant POV might tell those motivations.

Close Distance:
The zombie lunged through the open window. Oh crap! Bob grabbed the shogun and pulled the trigger. 

Jane bit back a frustrated scream. There was never a shotgun around when you needed it. She spotted an axe hanging behind the bar. That'll do. 
Far Distance:
Bob reached for the shogun to blow the zombie's head off. Oh crap! he thought, and pulled the trigger.

Jane ran for the axe hanging behind the bar. She realized there was never a shotgun around when you needed it.
Emotional Signposts
These are words like: felt, thought, sensed, believed, realized, ignored. They explain to the reader what the narrator is thinking or feeling instead of showing actions that let the reader figure out these things. Now, there's a difference between a distant narrator and telling, though it can be a subtle thing. You fall more into telling when you rely on the explanation to convey the information, and do nothing in the text to back that up. It's also more told when there's no sense of a narrator to those explanations, juts the author filling in the gaps.

Telling: Jane sensed the zombie just beyond the edge of the light. They'd found her.
Showing:  Jane sensed the zombie just beyond the edge of the light; a presence in the darkness, a lurking hunger, she wasn't sure what it was, but her body knew. They'd found her.

Telling: Bob ignored the warning signs that zombies were close and went in anyway.

Showing: Bob ignored the warning signs: the shuffling feet, the scrapping, the smell. He went in anyway. 

Easy Explanations
These are words like: by, since, after, when, before. They're explaining the order of events from a distance because the narrator knows what happened. Or it's summing up a decision that the reader never gets to see the POV character make.
By the time Bob got to the gun, the zombie had broken through the door.

Since Jane was already on top of the dumpster, Bob ran for the Chevy Suburban.

When Sally came out of the house, then zombies charged at her.
Pitfalls of Narrative Distance
It makes it easy to tell instead of show, and claim you're just doing a far narrative distance. But if you decide on far, make sure the one doing the telling is a narrator, not the author poking in to explain things, even if that narrator is invisible. It's a subtle difference, but it makes a world of difference between a story that feels flat, and story that feels like someone is telling it. 

On the flip side, a close narrative distance makes it easy to throw in every single thing a character thinks and does, so the story bogs down. Even though you're close in your narrator's head, you don't have to show every last thing they think or do. You can summarize a bit or skip things entirely if they story reads better that way. It's all about balance.

Which Narrative Distance Do You Use?
It's just like POV. Whichever you prefer. It all depends on how close in the head of your narrator and POV you want the reader to be. The closer you get, the more focused what is seen becomes. The more personal and judgmental (as in, they judge what they see and have an opinion about it, not the snotty type).

ETA: You hear all the time about filter words and POV, and Juliette Wade did a fabulous post on this. A must read if you really want to get this concept.

19 comments:

salarsenッ said...

This is a really well-written post. Great for any writer. Tweeting you.

Natalie Aguirre said...

Great post and answers some questions for me about third person limited. I didn't realize adding "he thought" adds some distance. I have seen a few authors, like in Tyger, Tyger, do third person limited without the "he thought" and without italics. I'll need to pay more attention to this. Thanks.

Terry Odell said...

I write deep POV. I don't want "ME" on the page. Even in narration, I try to remain true to each character's voice. There should never be a jolt between "the character is talking" and "someone else is talking" for the reader.

Terry
Terry's Place
Romance with a Twist--of Mystery

Carol Riggs said...

Excellent post (another one going into my Writing Documents for posterity and later reference!).

I really like to use the deep POV too, and I don't like the "he thought" and "she thought" tags at all. They feel intrusive to me. I'm just beginning to know what you're talking about between the subtle diff between narrative distance and Telling, too. Good stuff!

A.B. Fenner said...

I think I have at least ten of your blog posts bookmarked, and I just added this one. These are such great references, especially in the editing phase. Thanks so much!

Myne Whitman said...

I will also be bookmarking this. First time here and I learn a new thing. I've not heard of the difference in telling and far narrative distance. I also use the deep POV, it comes more naturally to me.

Janice Hardy said...

Salarsen: Thanks so much!

Natalie: There are so many ways to add or reduce distance. Finally getting this was another major light bulb moment for me, actually. I'm always amazed at how tiny word changes can affect the text on so many levels. Maybe it's the geek in me, but I think this stuff is so cool :)

Terry: I totally agree. Deep POV is my favorite, too, both to read and write.

Carol: Thanks! Narrative distance is such a cool thing to play with. All aspects of POV have enormous range on what you can do with them.

A.B. Fenner: Most welcome :)

Myne: Welcome to the blog! Lots of deep POV fans here as well ;) It's my favorite, too.

rachelblom said...

I have to tell you: I have learned more from your posts on POV than from many books I read. All your posts are awesome for that matter, I just keep adding them to my Evernote 'writing' folder. You make it so practical and every time I've read a post, I go back to my writing and fix mistakes. Thanks a lot!

Janice Hardy said...

Thanks!I do try to do more than just say "this is how you do it." I strive to find things you can do to improve and see the changes in your work.

Shannon said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Shannon said...

Err, sorry, removed the wrong post on the wrong blog. My bad. I was just saying that I went back and evaluated when I used each of those words and found that I use 'felt' a lot when I don't need to. By rewording it, my pages read a lot better. Sensed, thought, and realized, I rarely used and when I did it was with a purpose. It's amazing the things your blog teaches! I guess that's why you're my absolute favoritest blogger.

Janice Hardy said...

Awesome :) And thanks so much! Hearing that makes all the work worth it.

Kristi Helvig said...

Oh, I love this post--I'm linking to it tomorrow! :)

Janice Hardy said...

Thanks!

gabi said...

Wow, great post! I've been thinking of doing a post on narrative distance and will definitely link to this when I do. Just found your blog today but am loving it already!

Matthew Rush said...

I've only written the one novel, and the first draft was third person limited, but I tried to keep the narrative distance pretty close. The novel ended up going on way to long, or rather I did, while writing it, but I've since re-written it into first person, so I suppose the distance is even that much closer now.

Great post! Thanks so much.

Janice Hardy said...

Gabi: Welcome to the blog, and thanks for the future link!

Matthew: So which do you like better? First or third?

Henya said...

Narrative distance is a delicate balance I often have difficulty with. I just love the examples you've added to your post.
Thanks.

Janice Hardy said...

Most welcome ;)