Thursday, March 8

And the Pace is On: Understanding and Controlling Your Pacing

By Janice Hardy, @Janice_Hardy

My husband isn't a YA reader (though I'm trying to change that) and when he read my book for the first time, one of his comments was:
"Wow, you do stuff in three pages that would take an adult book three chapters."
An exaggeration, but there's truth in there. YA is usually faster paced that adult work, because kids won't put up with something that drags. They're busy folks, and if you can't grab and hold their attention, you're a goner.

Pacing is one way to keep that attention.

What is pacing? It's the speed of your prose.

Different types of sentences read at different speeds. So do certain events. The adage, "time flies when you're having fun" really does apply, as things that we're really into fly by, and things we're not as invested in bog us down. Just like your favorite class in school was too short, but your least favorite was three times as long.

You can control your pacing by how you organize information for to the reader.

Dialog tends to read quickly because it's a lot of short sentences in a row. Descriptive passages read more slowly, because there are a lot of longer sentences in a row. But it isn't that simple, because fast-paced dialog that is basically two people saying hello and exchanging small talk is boring and slows the story, even if the dialog itself reads quickly. Gripping description that sets the mood and clearly shows something about to happen can grab a reader, even if it takes longer to read.

It's how you put it all together that determines the pace.

Shorter sentences pick up the pace. They're quick and easy to read. They give information fast, so we don't have to remember much per sentence. They can also get the heart pumping, as they simulate something happening quickly. That's why action scenes are often filled with short punchy sentences.

Long sentences slow things down. It takes longer to read a sentence with lots of clauses and information in it, because we have to think more carefully about what we read. This is doubly true if there are a lot of long sentences in the same paragraph, because they usually build off one another and the entire paragraph contains one large thought of some kind. Quite often, the language itself it written in a way that draws attention to it so we can savor the words themselves as well as what they say.

Did you notice the difference in pacing between those two paragraphs? Odds are you read through the first pretty quickly. The second probably took a little more time. You may have even had to re-read something.

How much information the reader is required to absorb also influences pacing. Throw a lot of details at them, and they're forced to slow down. That's why dialog reads so fast. People talking usually aren't conveying information we need to remember. We take it in, understand it, and move on. We're trained to do that since that how we communicate on a daily basis. Same with action scenes, as the information offered is visual and direct. Someone acts, something happens. There's not a lot of room for interpretation, so it's easy to absorb.

Description is the opposite. We start building images in our minds with the first detail, but as you add more, we mentally hold them and wait for all the details before we have that image solid in our heads. Often, we want to make sure we have it right before we continue reading. This might be done in a second or two, but it slows the mind down and we notice slow spots even if we don't know why.

Does that mean you always want a fast pace? Nope. Breakneck prose is exhausting to read. So much is flung at you so fast it becomes a blur. Even if there is less information to remember, it went by so fast you didn't have time to retain any of it.

As with most things, balance and moderation work best. Keep things moving, but after a particularly fast scene, let the pace slow down so the reader has a chance to reflect and absorb what just happened. Cycle through fast and slow scenes like waves, getting a little higher every time as you build momentum and increase stakes.

Don't think slow paced means boring. There are other ways to maintain narrative drive, even in a slower scene. Tap into the emotional state of your characters. If they're worried about something, that can keep readers wondering. So can secrets or mysteries dangled like carrots. Slower-paced scenes are good places to play up the who and why, while action scenes usually focus on the what and how.

Unpredictability is another useful tool in controlling your pace. If the reader can see where things are going, they'll anticipate and assume what will happen before it does. That steals a lot of the drive from your scenes, even if they're fast paced. But if the reader is kept guessing, and characters do what they don't expect, then even a slow-paced scene becomes gripping.

Do you prefer a fast or slow pace? Have you noticed a trend in pacing for the different genres you read?

17 comments:

  1. Thanks for all the help and information in this blog. I found it had some really good pointers.
    thanks for sharing

    ReplyDelete
  2. Great post and great description and illustration in your paragraphs. ;) I caught it while I was reading. This is something that I need to be reminded of, especially during rewrites.:p

    ReplyDelete
  3. That is a clever comment. Where did you find it?

    ReplyDelete
  4. BJ Kerry, most welcome, glad you find it helpful :)

    Amelia, thanks! Revision is a good time to really dig into pacing since you know how the story unfolds.

    C0, which comment? I wrote the post, so it's all me.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I prefer fact pacing when it comes to genre fiction. There's nothing worse than wading through page after page of exposition just to describe the world. In SF I want action interspersed with world building.

    I like literary works that meander, more streaming consciousness style. Then I'm not reading for plot but more for atmosphere and character so a slower pace is sometimes even better.

    In my writing, I'm still working on pacing. Sometimes I rush through things and sometimes I get overly descriptive, so it's still a balancing act for me.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Xan, I love that you do indeed enjoy different pacing based on what you're reading. A great example of how not every book has to be one way.

    ReplyDelete
  7. I've heard that teaching pacing is like teaching grace--some people just have it naturally.

    This is great info. It helps people make conscious choices and know why they work.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Great post! Pacing is something I always try to work at. Another related issue is pacing of plot--some subplots slow the pace down, but others can provide necessary layering. It's a hard balance.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Where's the 'Like' button? LOL. Seriously, another great post, Janice, especially the point about tapping into emotional states and dangling secrets or mysteries. Brilliant!

    ReplyDelete
  10. Pacing is a challenge for me, but thankfully my beta readers can highlight where I'm moving too fast or too slow. Thanks for the great advice!

    ReplyDelete
  11. Angela, I can believe that. Anything that takes an ear to hear is something that's hard to teach as well as learn. Much harder to develop an ear for it, but I think it can be done. Just takes lots of reading :)

    Writer Librarian, so true. That's probably more of a goal-hook issue though. But an interesting scene that drags on too long is a pacing problem.

    Dario, I have no like button? Oh no, I mist fix that. How the heck *do* I fix that? But yeah, it's those "I wanna know!" things that really keep you reading.

    Julie, good betas! I love when mine point out stuff like that. So very helpful.

    ReplyDelete
  12. I wonder if faster pace is the reason why YA is quite popular with adults right now.

    ReplyDelete
  13. I read a lot of YA and have grown used to the fast pace, and love it. On the more wordy "adult" books I often skim and sigh with relief when finishing them (which is a good lesson in itself).

    This is a very helpful post, reminding us of some key points to having good flow.

    Thanks so much - again!!

    ReplyDelete
  14. As always, awesome advice. I've been thinking about pacing this week because the piece I'm starting is more literary and therefore a little slower. So different from the fast-paced stuff I'm used to writing.

    ReplyDelete
  15. Another fine post, Janice.

    Pacing is a challenge for me at times, but on the upside, it's easier to tell when pacing's slow than the more subtle (or not so subtle) tense shifts I make sometimes.

    It can be really hard to get the right emotions and action beats without unconditionally shifting tense, and just one word can do that, and trips readers up, even if they don't get it's because of a tense shift due to an out of tense pronoun or something.

    This proves invaluable to my process since I recently figured this out. Now there will be one draft in my revision process where the only thing I look for is awkward and unintentional tense shifts, and ask one my trusted readers to only focus on when I lapse out of the intended tense or POV, because that will make the other editing WAY less nightmarish.

    While I understand your husband's initial reactions about pacing, thanks for making the point that slower-paced beats and scenes in a story has its place.

    For the same reason, people who are overly anal about axing adverbs, and not being so specific that you leave no room for the imagination.

    I think we sometimes forget that just like writers all write different, readers are just as if not more diverse in what and how they read.

    A few writers I know find some of my favorite books too slowly paced for them, but these were definitive authors for me, and still are, so sometimes it's hard to discern if what bugs us about pacing is personally subjective versus universally problematic for any reader. Don't you agree, Janice? Anyone else?

    Take Care,
    Taurean

    ReplyDelete
  16. Jo-Ann, it's one reason for me. Busier days mean less time, and I can sit down for an evening and zip through a YA novel. I get right into them. I can easily see that being an appeal to others.

    Patti, I have that same issue with some adult novels. They feel a lot slower to me, and I have to remind myself to stop and just smell the literary roses.

    Annalisa, pacing is still valuable in literary work, but yes, it's a lot slower. One fantastic literary novel with wonderful pacing I've read is The Thirteenth Tale. (I think it's by Diane Setterfield). A quiet story, not a lot of action, but I couldn't put it down (once past the first few chapters. It started slow for me, but I suspect that's the market). It keep the story moving through hooking the reader, not through traditional "action scene" type plot.

    Traci, thanks!

    Taurean, totally. We all have preferences, and all are valid. Pacing is all about the speed the of text, and that can be fast or slow. Both have their places, and both have their fans.

    ReplyDelete