The Q&A continues today with...
Q: When writing in third person, it reads awkward to internalize the MC's questions. At a conference, agents said just tell the reader...don't put in awkward questions. We all know show don't tell, but when should you just tell the reader. Examples of this in third person would also be great.A: Although this is specific to third person questions, I think it also applies to first person to a lesser degree. (Full disclosure: I write mostly first person and I love internalized questions) They're great placeholder sentences to show where you might want to create some mystery, so feel free to use them as much as you want in a first draft. But for later drafts, consider how many are helping your novel vs hurting it, and revise accordingly.
The problem with internalized questions is that they can feel like you're whacking readers in the head with what they ought to be thinking or wondering about, instead of dropping clues that make them wonder about it. For example:
She crumpled the note in her hands. "Sorry?" she whispered. He walked out on her and all he could write was sorry? Was it another woman? Did he meet some hussy in the law school she paid for? Slaved for? Had he been using her all these years? That jerk. She'd never been anything but a cash cow to him. She flung the note across the room. How could he do this to her?While these are all questions someone in this situation would reasonably think, there leaves little here for readers to wonder about on their own. It also feels like this is indeed the case and there's no other possible reason for the situation. The questions lead too much and this ultimately feel too on the nose. Even worse, it gives the story nowhere to go, as the character isn't doing anything to move the story forward, she's just spouting questions. But let's "answer" these questions instead and show what the character would think if she'd already considered these questions and decided what they all mean.
She crumpled the note in her hands. "Sorry?" she whispered. He walked out on her and all he could write was sorry? That jerk. She'd never been anything but a cash cow to him--hell, she'd even financed his quest for a "more suitable wife" like an idiot. She flung the note across the room. This wasn't over. Oh no.Instead of telling readers what they should be thinking, this shows what the character is thinking, and it's easy to see what emotion she's feeling about this. Readers will likely wonder if there is another woman, and try to remember if there were any clues to suggest it. They're probably also curious to see what the character does next, as this gives the sense the character is going to act, and odds are it won't be pretty.
(Here's more on crafting natural sounding internal thoughts)
Reasons to Use Internal Questions
When it's something the character would believably ask in that situation that also reinforces her emotional state
Sometimes we do ask internal questions, especially if we're angry or upset. "How could he do this to me?" is a good (if clichéd) example. "Is he serious?" is another. Thoughts that could be spoken aloud often work just fine as internal questions. (Though it's fun to see how the scene would go if the character actually did say them out loud)
When you want to remind readers of the goal of the scene or novel
An internal question can work as a scene goal statement: "where was the murder weapon?" This shows the character is probably going to be looking for this item. "What if she was wasn't at the bar?" suggests figuring this out is important. It can also tell readers what the overall story question is, and what the book is trying to resolve: "So what really happened to Mario?"
When it would create more mystery, tension, or a dramatic pause
Questions can work as those "dum-dum-DUM!" cliffhanger moments to raise tension or hook readers. It might be a revelation: "Did that mean John was alive?" Or an internal conflict the character will be struggling with: "Could she trust him?"
When it would show a different attitude or opinion from what the narrator is displaying
Sometimes a character feels one way internally, but is forced (or wants) to show a different attitude or emotion externally. An internal question can be a great way to show this dichotomy. What kind of moron was he? She nodded. "You make a good point."
When a character is debating with themselves
Although you have to be careful here (it's easy to go to far), questions can be a handy way to show a character having an internal debate. This can be especially helpful if you need to show how a character had made a connection or a leap in logic that might feel contrived without the explanation.
(Here's more on showing vs telling internal thoughts)
Reasons Not to Use Internal Questions
When it's there solely to lead readers to the conclusion you want them to make
If the question is there to tell readers what to think, and there's no room for any other option, you might want to cut it. If readers can't get to that question on their own by what they see in the text, and there's no reason (or a weak reason) for the character to ask it, there's a good chance it's going to feel awkward.
When it feels repetitious
Like my first example, a lot of questions in a row can feel like you're badgering the reader, especially if they all basically say the same thing. Try showing internal thoughts or actions that suggest those questions (or answers to those questions) instead.
When it doesn't convey any real information to move the story
Empty internal questions can feel like empty dialog. It's not necessary to understand anything in the scene, but it feels like it ought to be said. Try cutting it and seeing which version reads better.
When it's redundant
If the internal question is followed up by thoughts, action, or dialog that implies the same question, there's no need to shine a light on it. For example, if the character is staring at a crime scene and describing it in detail, starting or ending with "what happened here?" isn't really necessary.
(Here's more on choosing which thoughts to italicize)
When in Doubt...
If you're not sure if the question should stay or go, ask yourself:
- Does it read well without it?
- Is it shoving the idea/thought/mystery in the reader's face?
- Would the reader ask the same question from seeing what's in the scene?
- Does it feel awkward?
Internal questions are a great tool to show what a character is struggling with and what they're trying to do, but it can be overused if we aren't careful. Trust your instincts--if if feels awkward or melodramatic, odds are it is and cutting it would strengthen the scene (reading it out loud is a good test for melodrama).
How do you feel about internal questions? Love them? Hate them? Never gave them a second thought?
Looking for tips on revising or planning your novel? Check out my newest book Planning Your Novel: Ideas and Structure, a series of self-guided workshops that help you turn your idea into a novel. It's also a great guide for revisions!
Janice Hardy is the founder of Fiction University, and the author of the teen fantasy trilogy The Healing Wars, where she tapped into her own dark side to create a world where healing was dangerous, and those with the best intentions often made the worst choices. Her novels include The Shifter, (Picked as one of the 10 Books All Young Georgians Should Read, 2014) Blue Fire, and Darkfall from Balzer+Bray/Harper Collins. The first book in her Foundations of Fiction series, Planning Your Novel: Ideas and Structure is out now. She is also a contributor at Pub(lishing) Crawl, and Writers in the Storm.
Website | Facebook | Twitter | Goodreads | Amazon | Barnes & Noble | Indie Bound