From Fiction University: Enabling third party cookies on your browser could help if you have trouble leaving a comment.

Friday, March 30

The End is Near: What Makes a Good Ending?

By Janice Hardy, @Janice_Hardy

Some writers have troubles with beginnings, or more commonly, middles, but for me, it’s endings.

I tend to rush them once I get close, summarizing instead of letting things build to the big bang. I always have to rewrite them, usually several times before I get them right. These days, I work hard to figure out my ending before I start the book. I've learned (the hard way) that the easiest books for me to write are the ones where I know my ending ahead of time.

What makes a good ending? 

Tastes will vary of course, but generally, readers want to see the problem the book has been exploring all along resolved in a satisfying way. They want to be surprised by something they didn’t see coming, but a surprise that still fits with the story – not something out of the blue they couldn’t have figured out on their own. They want to see the protagonist grow or change in some fashion that made everything she went through in the book matter in a personal and meaningful way.

(Here's more on writing great endings)

Yeah, but how do you do that? 

Endings start long before the actual climax, because that’s when you start laying the groundwork for them. You probably have some idea of how you want your story to end. There’s a good chance it’s part of your one-sentence “this is what my book is about” line. Everything in the story has been building to this moment. If it hasn’t? Then that's a red flag for why your ending is giving you trouble. Try looking through your story and asking:

What constitutes a win for your protagonist? If you’re not sure, look at your beginning. What major thing happened that set your protagonist on her journey? What has she been trying to accomplish all along? That’s what you’ll need to resolve in some way in your ending.

What constitutes a win for your reader? You’ve set up certain expectations throughout the book and your reader is going to want to see those expectations satisfied. What promises did you make? What problems did you dangle? What risks were taken that hinted at greater consequences?

(Here are five common problems with endings)

Are you escalating the stakes? 

The first draft of The Shifter had this problem. The ending was exciting, but it didn’t raise the stakes any higher from the major event at the end of the third act. Because of that, the ending was just kinda there. My agent had me revise it, and she gave me some advice that really changed my thinking. She said to go deeper, not wider, with the story, and to tie it in thematically to Nya’s struggle.

At first, I didn’t understand what she meant, but then I figured out that it’s easy to add more stuff to make things harder on your protagonist, but the stakes aren’t really higher. More lives in jeopardy isn’t high stakes because readers don’t know those people. They care about the characters.

Look at what your protagonist has at stake on a personal level. Look at how that ties into the story from a thematic aspect, so the ending has more poignancy. For The Shifter, it was about being trapped, so feeling trapped factored into the climax. Same with the sequel, Blue Fire, but this time it was all about escape. In Darkfall, if was about fighting back. Those ideas influenced what was done so it tied into the rest of the story.
  • What inner conflict has your protagonist been struggling with all along?
  • How can you make that inner conflict butt heads with the outer problem in your climax?
  • How might that inner conflict influence what the protagonist needs to do to solve the final problem?
  • How might the theme be used to make the ending more powerful, and thus raise the stakes?
  • What can you do to make the risk more personal for your protagonist?  
(Here's more on writing the final showdown) 

    You were saying something about a surprise? 

    Endings we can see coming a mile away bore us, but the fact is, we pretty much know the hero is going to win in any book we pick up. There is only so much mystery you can squeeze out of “will the protagonist win or not?” The tension and wonder will come from how they do it and what it might cost them. This is why personal stakes are so critical. But we also need to have our protagonist act in a way that is unexpected, so the way they solve the problem is a surprise.

    One thing I like to do is look at the moral beliefs of my protagonist and have her do something she’d never consider doing otherwise. But the trick is, she still has to be true to herself. She can’t just throw out all she believes in. She has to make that choice, hard as it is, for reasons that fit who she is.

    Maybe it was a line she refused to cross before, or a risk she was never willing to take. Something that might even have been suggested earlier in the novel and rejected. But the stakes are higher now, and not doing it will result in something far worse than doing it. It’s a sacrifice she’s willing to make, even though it’s going to cost her a lot.

    How do we get her to that point? 

    This is where the thrill building comes in. It takes time to heap enough horrible onto your protagonist so that she’s willing to throw it all away for the win. A good place to start is around the end of the third act, when the protagonist has just hit a wall or found a problem that seems insurmountable. She’s trying to solve it, really feels that she’s not going to be able to, but knowing she has no choice but to try.

    Pacing is critical here, because speeding things up helps build that breathless on the edge of your seat feeling. Let your characters worry a bit more, think a bit less. Things start going wrong and cascade into more and more trouble. Everything tried fails or makes things worse. Put your protagonist on that slippery slope, and don’t give her a lot of time to catch her breath. Let her struggle, let things get worse and worse but she still manages to squeak by. Then hit her with the climax, and the start of the end.

    Let her lose. Not “lose” lose, but force her into a position where she really has to think outside the box, find something unexpected and crazy that no one will see coming. For this to work, she has to be pushed beyond anything you’ve done to her so far. Feeling like it’s all or nothing, do or die, will put her right where she needs to be. And it forces you to think of over the top, last ditch efforts for her to succeed.

    (Here's more on writing the bittersweet ending)

    Whatever your ending, remember that it’s only as good as what’s come before it. The entire story builds to this moment, and everything your protagonist has done will be put to the test in some way to solve this final problem.

    Look back and find things you can pull forward: stakes you can raise again, failures you can revisit, problems you can exacerbate. The ending is the climax of all of this, so it makes sense that all of this will provide the tools – and fodder – for your protagonist to save the day. Or not, if that’s the kind of ending you want. No one says your ending has to be happy.

    What do you feel makes the best endings?
    For more help on plotting or writing a novel check out my Plotting Your Novel: Ideas and Structure.

    Go step-by-step through plotting and writing a novel. Learn how to find and develop ideas, brainstorm stories from that first spark of inspiration, develop the right characters, setting, plots and subplots, as well as teach you how to identify where your novel fits in the market, and if your idea has what it takes to be a series.

    With clear and easy-to-understand examples, Plotting Your Novel: Ideas and Structure offers ten self-guided workshops with more than 100 different exercises to help you craft a solid novel. Learn how to:
    • Create compelling characters readers will love
    • Choose the right point of view for your story
    • Determine the conflicts that will drive your plot (and hook readers!)
    • Find the best writing process for your writing style
    • Create a solid plot from the spark of your idea
    Plotting Your Novel: Ideas and Structure also helps you develop the critical elements for submitting and selling your novel once it’s finished. You’ll find exercises on how to:
    • Craft your one-sentence pitch
    • Create your summary hook blurb
    • Develop a solid working synopsis And so much more!
    Plotting Your Novel: Ideas and Structure is an easy-to-follow guide to writing your novel or fixing a novel that isn’t quite working. 

    Available in paperback and ebook formats.

    Janice Hardy is the award-winning author of the teen fantasy trilogy The Healing Wars, including The Shifter, Blue Fire, and Darkfall from Balzer+Bray/Harper Collins. The Shifter, was chosen for the 2014 list of "Ten Books All Young Georgians Should Read" from the Georgia Center for the Book.

    She also writes the Grace Harper urban fantasy series for adults under the name, J.T. Hardy.

    When she's not writing novels, she's teaching other writers how to improve their craft. She's the founder of Fiction University and has written multiple books on writing.
    Website | Facebook | Twitter | Pinterest | Goodreads | Amazon | Barnes & Noble | iTunes | Indie Bound

    Originally posted during the Blue Fire blog tour at Abby Annis.


    1. I am struggling with this. In rewrite #3 of my novel, I wrote my ending soon after my beginning and am now beginning act 3...Problem is, I feel everything is happening way too fast. At what point do high stakes, action, mysteries unraveling become exhausting for the reader? I feel my pacing is getting out of hand!

      1. In my last manuscript I wrote the ending after I was a third of the way into the story. It worked wonderfully allowing me to work through the middle part of the story, weaving in details and action as needed.

    2. Truly you are an inspiration Janice.

      I have to admit though, while I can see how ending a book or story can be hard, I honestly have a harder time starting. I either start too late, too early, or not it's just not written/rewritten well, even if I know I'm starting in the right place.

      I struggle most with getting the reader to CARE, right at the start, rather than think, "Who cares?" which you know has driven me to both the Heartbreak Hotel and the Insane Asylum and back many times, since my feelings as the writer are different from what the reader feels, no matter how long I let things get cold before going back to revise.

      I'm always going to know things the reader won't, and some of what I can't get on the page organically now is necessary for the reader to see what I'm trying so hard to show, and knowing what must be shown NOW, and not ten pages or chapters from now, if at all, is not always straightforward.

      I hope I can find something to help me in your archives.


    3. Roberta: If you feel that way, trust your instincts. Look for spots where you can slow down, or add a scene that's more reflective. Something that focuses on the internal conflicts instead of the external. You don't want to drop the tension, but too much too fast *does* get exhausting. Also, major turning points are a good spot to slow down a bit because you've usually just done something huge, so you have lots of momentum to carry you through a slower moment. There's more on pacing Tuesday from author Jana DeLeon, so hopefully she will give you some more ideas.

      Taurean: Everyone has their sticking points :) Mine used to be middle back in the day and I figured them out. (now it's endings, go figure) If you go to the tag listings on the left hand side, you'll see a tag called "beginnings." That'll bring up all the articles on beginnings. Hopefully there will be something there that helps ;)

    4. when studying screenwriting I memorized this: before you begin writing the script, know the end. everything builds to the finale. you describe this process perfectly!

    5. Janice, I'd love to hear more about your struggles with middles, and how you developed a plan for them!

    6. Crud. Lost long comment. :(

      Could you talk more about sad endings? What makes a sad ending feel like an ending at all, if the central character has [i]still[/i] failed to accomplish his or her goal?

      I have an unhappy short story I'm shopping around, and one critter just told me the ending fizzles, as though I wasn't really sure what my point was. Thing is, it's the ending I was working toward all along. Now it could just be his opinion, but I'm trying to see if maybe I made it seem if I was building toward something else.

    7. @Joe -- Maybe it's not clear that the goal has failed utterly? Sometimes with "sad" endings, I get the feeling that a story just stopped in the middle of a try/fail cycle instead of reaching the conclusion.

    8. *nod* I'm wondering if I've dropped the ball on the internal vs. external goal department. The external goal has failed utterly, but I'm thinking now that I haven't really paid attention to his internal goal, and maybe that's why it's still not clear.

    9. I'm having the same problem with my ending. I know how I want to end it but I know it's way too fast and uncomplicated. I don't want my ending to be one big info dump. "This is what happened" and so one and so forth. This is, however, my first draft and I shouldn't be worrying about getting it perfect but getting it done. Great post!

    10. This is exactly the kind of through process I use for planning my own endings. I like seeing what my protagonist is willing to lose in order to triumph.

      I also like seeing the events buld towards what I call the "Luke Skywalker Moment," the part of the story where the odds keep getting stacked in favour of the antagonists, and the reader starts to realise that soon the protagonist will be the only person who can overcome the threat, as with the Death Star battle in Star Wars. :-)

    11. I have trouble keeping myself from rushing through endings too, whether I'm reading or writing. I'll be in such a hurry to find out what happens at the end, I'll blow through the last chapter of a book and miss most of what happens. It's only during subsequent reads that I discover how much of the ending I missed the first time. I just can't help it.

    12. Endings:
      Would-be novelist meets publisher
      "how long is a novel?"
      Publisher (sarcastically) "Seventy thousand words "
      Novelist "Then I've finished! Yippee!"

      Word Count Rules OK

    13. Great post, as usual, Janice. :) I'd also love to see how you've devised a plan to tackle "the middle"!

    14. Ann: Thanks! I know there are folks out there who like to discover the ending as they write, but I can't get started without knowing the end in some way.

      Melissa: Will do. :)

      Joe: Ooo I hate when that happens. Sad endings are tough, because a good ending satisfies the reader and they usually don't want to be unhappy by the end. So the trick is to have a sad ending that in some way is what the reader hopes for or understands is the right way to go for that character. I think theme plays a stronger role in sad endings as well, because winning isn't the goal. A larger purpose is typically conveyed in a sad ending.

      I'd suggest looking back at your beginning and see what you hinted at as being a "win" for your protag. If readers are expecting that to happen, and it doesn't, and the protag fails, it's likely they'd be upset by that. You can also see if there's a way to let the protag win in a way that also allows the sad ending. Like when a hero sacrifices themselves to save the world kinda deal. Does that help?

      Megan: Good observation.

      Hannah: So true, get the story down, then fiddle as much as you want. I always infodump my first draft endings and have to fix them. Once you see how it plays out, you'll have a better sense of what to dramatize and what to sum up.

      Paul: I think we have the same writing process :)

      Chemist Ken: If the book is really good, I do that in the third act right before the ending. I'm in a hurry and I rush through it. Then have to go back and read stuff over.

      DJ Harrison: LOL If only it were that easy!

      Heather: Thanks! More on middles on Thursday.

    15. Endings can be so hard to figure out for a writer. Really the entire novel or memoir hinges on it and it makes the difference between a memorable book that you'll be talking about for years to come and a forgettable one. Great post!

    16. Indeed. It's the last thing a reader takes away from the book, and if that's a bad taste, it affects the entire novel.

    17. Hi Janice,
      I'd like to talk more about sad ending. I somehow like a sad ending, because it's kinda tell your reader that sometimes things doesn't always go like you want. The guy doesn't always get the girl. And maybe it can make your reader want a continuation of the story itself.
      I guess if it's executed perfectly, it can has a much more powerful impact rather than a happy ending.
      For example, Romeo and Juliet, they didn't have a happy ending, they're both dead, but the story is still being told up till now, or Titanic for another example.

      But somehow I also think that a sad ending makes readers feel pointless, dissapointed and asking 'what's the point of reading this story?' how do you get around that?

    18. I like a sad ending every now and then, too. I read (and write) women's fiction, and sometimes you'll get one of those. Or a bittersweet ending. In romance, of course, the couple must have their HEA/HFN.

      I cannot begin writing a story in earnest until I know the ending. How else will I know what to write toward? Of course, I may not know how I'll arrive at that ending. I figure that out as I go, pantsing and plotting along the way with that final image imprinted on my brain.

      As always, Janice, a helpful post filled with provocative questions to help the writer iron things out.

      1. I'm the same way with endings. I didn't used to be, and that caused a lot of trouble for me.

    19. My historical novel follows the historical record accurately, so my ending was cast in stone before I even started. Then I started thinking: "What about the guy who turned 'state's evidence' afterward?" I couldn't make it fit the story well enough, so I think I will offer it as a bonus: "All Debts Are Paid." It could be in an addendum or a download for those interested enough to want it. It's actually pretty interesting, and it happened on Christmas Day two years after the bad guys met their fate at the end of a rope.

      1. That would make it easier :) I like the bonus story. Readers love extra context. You could use it as a newsletter freebie, or just have it on your website.